Shall I Go to Cancun or Puerto Vallarta: Which Destination Is Better? (2025)
Updated: Feb 10
If you're planning a trip to Mexico, chances are you've come across two of its most popular destinations: Cancun and Puerto Vallarta. Both are renowned for their stunning beaches, vibrant culture, and excellent tourist amenities, but they offer very different experiences. Whether you're a beach lover, a history buff, or an adventure seeker, understanding the differences between Cancun and Puerto Vallarta will help you choose the perfect destination for your vacation.
Are you struggling to decide between Cancun or Puerto Vallarta? Discover which destination suits your style!
Here is our comprehensive guide to Puerto Vallarta: Top Activities, Things to Do and See in Puerto Vallarta, Mexico.
Here is our comprehensive guide to Cancun: The Best 50 Things to Do and See in Cancun, Mexico.
Last Spring in Cancun, we were forced to buy sunscreen lotions and and Imodium from there. Oh my! the price was a shock! $35 for a bottle of sunscreen! It is infinitely better to buy before you leave for Mexico. Compare your prices of travel essentials here:
Here's a breakdown of what sets these two Mexican hotspots apart.
Shall I Go to Cancun or Puerto Vallarta: Which Destination Is Better? (2025)
Disclaimer: This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Your support helps us run this site—thank you!
1. Location and Geography
Cancun:
Located on the Yucatán Peninsula in the state of Quintana Roo, Cancun sits along the Caribbean Sea. This means white sand beaches and turquoise waters that look like they're straight out of a travel magazine. The geography here is flat, and the surrounding area is known for its lush tropical jungles and cenotes (natural sinkholes).
For a full guide, please read The Best 50 Things to Do and See in Cancun, Mexico.
Puerto Vallarta:
Situated on the Pacific Coast in the state of Jalisco, Puerto Vallarta offers a completely different vibe. Its beaches are framed by the Sierra Madre Mountains, creating a dramatic backdrop. The sand here is darker and coarser compared to Cancun, and the waters of Banderas Bay have a deeper blue hue. The Pacific sunsets are breathtaking, making it a favorite for romantics and photographers alike.
For a full guide, please read Top Things to Do and See in Puerto Vallarta, Mexico.
2. Crowd and Noise
Cancun:
Cancun is one of Mexico's most popular tourist destinations, and the Hotel Zone can feel quite crowded, especially during peak seasons (December to April). The beaches, nightclubs, and attractions are bustling with tourists, making Cancun a lively but often noisy destination. If you're looking for tranquility, Cancun's all-inclusive resorts can provide respite, though the party atmosphere is still pervasive in the city overall.
Puerto Vallarta:
Puerto Vallarta has a more laid-back vibe and is generally less crowded than Cancun, particularly during the off-season. While the city is popular with a variety of travelers, it feels less overwhelming and chaotic than Cancun. Beaches in the city center can get busy, but quieter spots like Yelapa or Boca de Tomatlán offer peaceful escapes. Puerto Vallarta strikes a balance between lively and serene, making it ideal for those seeking a more relaxed experience.
3. Culture and Atmosphere
Cancun:
Cancun, while known primarily for its pristine beaches and luxurious resorts, offers its own unique blend of culture, albeit one that caters more heavily to international tourists. Unlike Puerto Vallarta's intimate connection to traditional Mexican heritage, Cancun’s cultural identity is often intertwined with its role as a global vacation hotspot. That said, there are opportunities to explore the region’s rich Mayan history, such as visiting nearby archaeological sites like Chichén Itzá, Tulum, or Cobá, which provide a fascinating glimpse into ancient civilizations. Cancun also celebrates its cultural diversity through vibrant events like Día de los Muertos (Day of the Dead) festivals and performances that showcase traditional Mexican music and dance. However, much of the city’s cultural experience is curated and polished for tourists, often blending Mexican traditions with a more cosmopolitan flair to cater to its international audience.
The atmosphere in Cancun is markedly different from Puerto Vallarta, offering a faster-paced, high-energy environment that revolves around its upscale resorts and nightlife. The Hotel Zone, the heart of Cancun’s tourist area, is buzzing with activity day and night, from beach clubs and water sports to world-class restaurants and electric nightclubs. Cancun’s vibe is one of luxury and indulgence, with its all-inclusive offerings giving visitors a sense of convenience and ease. While the natural beauty of the Caribbean Sea and white-sand beaches creates a postcard-perfect setting, the atmosphere often feels more commercialized and tailored for relaxation and entertainment rather than cultural immersion. For travelers seeking a vibrant, party-filled vacation with a touch of history, Cancun delivers, but it lacks the intimate, small-town charm that defines destinations like Puerto Vallarta.
Puerto Vallarta:
When it comes to culture and atmosphere, Puerto Vallarta offers a distinct charm that sets it apart from the more resort-centric vibe of Cancun. Puerto Vallarta is steeped in authentic Mexican traditions, with its cobblestone streets, colonial architecture, and vibrant local art scene providing a genuine sense of place. Unlike Cancun, which is largely shaped by its all-inclusive resorts and international influences, Puerto Vallarta feels more connected to its heritage. The city’s Malecón (boardwalk) is a cultural centerpiece, where you can experience a mix of modern sculptures, local artisans selling handcrafted goods, and traditional performances, such as folkloric dances or mariachi music. Dining in Puerto Vallarta also highlights its cultural richness, with everything from family-owned taquerías to upscale restaurants serving regional specialties like pescado zarandeado (grilled fish). It’s an ideal destination for travelers seeking an immersive and authentic Mexican experience.
The atmosphere of Puerto Vallarta is equally unique, offering a more laid-back and intimate energy compared to the high-octane, party-driven vibe often associated with Cancun. Puerto Vallarta’s charm lies in its blend of natural beauty and welcoming community. Nestled between the lush Sierra Madre mountains and the sparkling waters of Banderas Bay, the city exudes a relaxed tranquility that encourages exploration. Whether strolling through the Romantic Zone with its boutique shops and quaint cafes or enjoying an evening sunset on the beach, there’s a sense of connection to both the environment and the local culture. While Cancun caters heavily to international tourists with its mega-resorts and bustling nightlife, Puerto Vallarta feels more personal and approachable, making it a favorite for those seeking a slower pace and a deeper appreciation of Mexico's traditions and hospitality.
4. Friendliness of Mexican People
Cancun:
The locals in Cancun are generally friendly and welcoming, but the city’s heavy focus on tourism can make interactions feel more transactional, especially in the Hotel Zone. Staff at resorts and restaurants are professional and accommodating, but the city’s fast-paced tourism industry can sometimes detract from the personal warmth that Mexico is known for. If you venture into downtown Cancun or smaller nearby towns, you'll experience more genuine hospitality and friendliness from locals eager to share their culture.
Puerto Vallarta:
Puerto Vallarta is widely praised for the friendliness of its people. The city has a warm, community-oriented feel, and locals are approachable, eager to help, and genuinely welcoming to visitors. Whether you’re chatting with a vendor, a restaurant owner, or a local guide, you’ll likely feel their pride in their culture and hospitality. Puerto Vallarta's relaxed pace and close-knit atmosphere make it easy to connect with both locals and other travelers.
Read More:
5. Cost of Food and Accommodation
Cancun:
Cancun is generally more expensive, particularly in the Hotel Zone with its luxury all-inclusive resorts. While budget options do exist, such as accommodations in downtown Cancun, most visitors are drawn to the high-end beachfront properties.
Food prices in Cancun can also be higher, especially in tourist-heavy areas. Upscale dining, international cuisine, and resort restaurants dominate the scene, though local eateries in downtown Cancun offer more affordable and authentic meals. Expect to pay $10–$20 for a meal at a mid-range restaurant and significantly more at resort buffets or fine dining establishments.
Puerto Vallarta:
Puerto Vallarta is generally more affordable, offering a wide range of accommodations from budget hostels to boutique hotels and high-end resorts. You can find charming, reasonably priced lodgings in areas like the Romantic Zone or Old Town, while beachfront resorts are often less expensive compared to Cancun.
Food in Puerto Vallarta is also more budget-friendly. The city is known for its fantastic street food scene, where you can grab tacos for $1–$2 or enjoy a full meal at a local restaurant for $8–$15. Even upscale restaurants tend to be more reasonably priced compared to Cancun, and the quality of local, authentic cuisine is exceptional.
6. Expat Communities
Cancun:
Cancun’s expat community is smaller and more transient compared to Puerto Vallarta. Many expats in Cancun work in the tourism or hospitality industries, and the city attracts younger travelers and digital nomads who appreciate the modern amenities and vibrant nightlife. However, the focus on all-inclusive resorts and the fast-paced, tourist-heavy atmosphere can make it harder to connect with a long-term expat community.
Expats in Cancun often live in downtown Cancun, where the cost of living is lower, or in quieter residential areas like Puerto Morelos, which is about 30 minutes south of the city. Cancun is a great option for expats who enjoy a bustling, international vibe, but it may lack the close-knit expat networks found in other parts of Mexico.
Puerto Vallarta:
Puerto Vallarta has one of the largest and most established expat communities in Mexico. Many retirees, digital nomads, and long-term travelers choose Puerto Vallarta for its affordable cost of living, welcoming locals, and relaxed lifestyle. The expat community here is very active, with numerous social groups, meetups, and events that make it easy to build connections.
Popular expat neighborhoods include Zona Romántica, Marina Vallarta, and Nuevo Vallarta, which offer a mix of modern amenities, walkability, and proximity to the beach. Puerto Vallarta’s expat community is known for its inclusivity and friendliness, making it a top destination for those looking to relocate or spend extended time in Mexico.
7. Activities and Excursions
Cancun:
Cancun’s proximity to the Mayan Riviera makes it a hub for historical and natural excursions. Visitors can explore ancient Mayan ruins, swim in cenotes, or visit the eco-parks of Xcaret and Xel-Há. For water lovers, the nearby Isla Mujeres and Cozumel are must-visits for snorkeling and diving.
Puerto Vallarta:
Puerto Vallarta offers a mix of outdoor adventures and cultural experiences. You can visit the Marietas Islands for snorkeling, hike in the Sierra Madre Mountains, or take a day trip to the charming beach towns of Sayulita or Yelapa. Whale watching in Banderas Bay is a popular activity during the winter months. Additionally, walking tours through Puerto Vallarta’s historic neighborhoods can give you a deeper appreciation of the city’s history and culture.
8. Visiting with Family and Kids
Cancun:
Cancun is ideal for families seeking convenience and action-packed entertainment. Its all-inclusive resorts often cater to kids with splash pools, kids' clubs, and abundant activities, providing a stress-free stay for parents. The calm, shallow beaches in the Hotel Zone are perfect for young swimmers, while eco-parks like Xcaret and Xel-Há offer snorkeling, cenotes, and cultural shows. Compared to Puerto Vallarta, Cancun’s offerings feel more curated and resort-focused, making it an excellent choice for families wanting a structured, activity-filled vacation with modern amenities and easy access to iconic attractions like Mayan ruins.
Puerto Vallarta:
In contrast, Puerto Vallarta provides a more intimate, culturally immersive experience for families. Its cobblestone streets, local markets, and the lively Malecón allow families to explore authentic Mexican traditions in a relaxed setting. Adventurous families can enjoy boat trips, eco-tours, and quieter beaches like Conchas Chinas, fostering a connection to nature. While Cancun excels in modern infrastructure and kid-friendly attractions, Puerto Vallarta’s charm lies in its laid-back atmosphere and opportunities for cultural and outdoor exploration, ideal for families seeking a slower-paced, enriching getaway.
Read More:
7. Safety and Security
Cancun:
Cancun is generally safe for tourists, but safety depends on staying in well-traveled areas like the Hotel Zone, which is heavily monitored and secure for families, couples, and solo travelers. Walking at night in the Hotel Zone is relatively safe, but downtown Cancun and less touristy areas may pose risks, especially for solo travelers. Relaxing on the beach after dark is not recommended outside resort areas, as beaches can be poorly lit and sparsely monitored. Police are highly visible in tourist zones, but reports of corruption occasionally arise, such as targeting tourists for minor infractions or requesting bribes. To avoid issues, it’s best to stay in resort areas and handle any interactions with law enforcement calmly and respectfully.
Puerto Vallarta:
In contrast, Puerto Vallarta is smaller and has a more relaxed, community-focused vibe, which contributes to a greater sense of safety. Popular areas like the Malecón and Romantic Zone are generally safe for walking at night, even for solo travelers, but caution is still advised in quieter neighborhoods. Beaches in central areas remain lively into the evening, making them safer after dark compared to Cancun, though remote beaches like Playa Conchas Chinas should still be avoided. Police corruption is less commonly reported in Puerto Vallarta, and interactions with local authorities tend to feel less intimidating. Families often appreciate the town’s walkable streets and friendly atmosphere, while solo travelers feel more at ease exploring the area. Overall, Puerto Vallarta offers a slightly safer and more welcoming environment for all types of travelers.
Final Thoughts: Which Should You Choose?
The choice between Cancun and Puerto Vallarta ultimately depends on the type of vacation or lifestyle you’re seeking:
Choose Cancun if you want postcard-perfect beaches, lively nightlife, and easy access to Mayan ruins and cenotes. Cancun is ideal for those who enjoy a fast-paced, resort-focused experience, though it can feel crowded and pricier.
Choose Puerto Vallarta if you want to experience authentic Mexican culture, dramatic natural scenery, and a more affordable, laid-back environment. It’s also the better choice for those looking to connect with a friendly expat community.
Both destinations promise unforgettable experiences, so you can’t go wrong. Whether you’re sipping margaritas on a Caribbean beach or exploring the cobblestone streets of a Pacific coastal town, Mexico’s beauty and hospitality will leave you wanting more.
Where will your next adventure take you? 🌴
